Skip to content

Paranormal Warehouse

Real evidence. Strange stories. No easy answers.


  • News
  • UFO & UAP
  • Bigfoot
  • Ghosts
  • Case Files
  • Videos
  • PW Gaming
Submit Evidence
  1. Home
  2. Bigfoot & Cryptids
  3. Before It Was Mothman, the Newspaper Called It ‘Something’
Bigfoot & Cryptids, Case Files

Before It Was Mothman, the Newspaper Called It ‘Something’

Sixty years after two couples reported a winged figure near Point Pleasant, the first front page reads less like a monster story than a town trying to name what it had heard.

By Paranormal Warehouse

·

November 15, 2026

·

2–3 minutes
Green awning and storefront of the Mothman Museum in Point Pleasant, West Virginia, photographed in 2010.

The Mothman Museum, 2010. Richie Diesterheft, CC BY 2.0. Archival photograph.

On November 16, 1966, the Point Pleasant Register tried three words for whatever two couples said they’d seen the night before: bird, creature, and finally “something.” Sixty years later, that last word still does more honest work than the name that stuck.

Roger and Linda Scarberry and Steve and Mary Mallette said they had been driving near Point Pleasant, West Virginia, when they saw a tall, winged figure with red eyes. They said it followed their car. The Smithsonian’s account of the legend reproduces the original front page, where the couples’ story sits beneath the day’s lead headline.

The road out of the TNT area

The four were near the old West Virginia Ordnance Works, known locally as the TNT area. In the 1966 clipping, the creature looks awkward on the ground but reportedly keeps up with the car once it’s in the air. The paper says a sheriff’s deputy and a city policeman later went out to look. They didn’t find it.

That’s an easy detail to lose once the story starts getting told as a monster chase. There were four people reporting a frightening experience, followed by two officers who found nothing at the scene. Each part belongs in the story. Neither tells us what was in the headlights.

Black-and-white aerial photo of rows of staff houses and dormitories at West Virginia Ordnance Works in the 1940s.
Staff housing at the former West Virginia Ordnance Works, 1940s. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, public domain. This shows the wider area, not the encounter.

The bird that wouldn’t stay a bird

The West Virginia Archives’ clipping file makes the first week of the story especially fun to read. By November 17, one paper was already calling it “Moth Man.” Another offered its readers an owl, a goose or a prank. On November 19, the Huntington Herald-Dispatch printed the sandhill-crane theory. Giving the thing a name hadn’t ended the argument.

The story picked up a darker association after the Silver Bridge collapsed in December 1967, killing 46 people. The connection belongs to the folklore that grew around the sightings. The National Transportation Safety Board’s report traced the collapse to a fracture in a steel link in the suspension chain.

Sixty years later, the name has a front door

John Keel’s 1975 book The Mothman Prophecies helped take the story beyond the Ohio River. The 2002 film did it again. In Point Pleasant, the legend now has a museum, where the history of the reports is part of the attraction.

On November 16, Ohio State’s Humanities Institute will mark the anniversary in Columbus with museum curators and a screening of the film. The screening is at capacity, but the free 6 to 7 p.m. Eastern social hour is open according to the event listing.

The newspaper didn’t have a monster it could put on a poster that morning. It had four people who said they’d seen something, and a headline that left room for doubt. The name came quickly. The answer never did.

Read next

Manufactured Feejee mermaid exhibit with a toothed head and fishlike tail at Harvard’s Peabody Museum.
Peabody Museum exhibit, 2017. Daderot / Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

How the Feejee mermaid became a museum attraction

A separate story about what happens when a strange claim becomes something people pay to see.

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading…

Make your inbox a little stranger.

Join Mike & Chris for The Weird Week: strange cases, footage worth a second look, and evidence you can weigh for yourself.

Subscribe to The Weird Week. Confirm your email to join. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy.

Check your inbox

One more step: click the confirmation link in our email to join The Weird Week. Check your spam folder if you do not see it.


PW EDITORIAL STANDARD — Paranormal Warehouse separates reported claims from verified facts whenever possible. Read our Editorial Policy.

KEEP READING

Saudi Arabia’s Empty Quarter Once Had Hippos. Its Lost Lake Still Holds Stone Tools.
An Oregon Family Reported Two UFO Sightings. What Does Their Photo Show?

Browse all case files →


Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Paranormal Warehouse

Real evidence. Strange stories. No easy answers.

About    Editorial Policy    Privacy Policy    Contact    Submit Evidence


Independent paranormal media · Paranormal Warehouse

Loading Comments...
%d